Cocktail with a lemon peel

Grandlife guide

LEGENDS OF THE FALL: COCKTAILS FOR THE SEASON

back to list

When fall rolls around, baristas start whipping up pumpkin spice everything. As for New York’s finest bartenders? They possess their own set of preferred ingredients and flavors when concocting fall cocktails.

“Cinnamon, maple syrup, anise, bourbons, and Scotch,” is what Peter Ruppert, the mustachioed barman at East Village restaurant Lucien, reaches for once the leaves start changing colors and clothing gets layered. “Something that breathes in the essence of the season; and hot toddies or warm apple cider—you know they will work.”

Ruppert, who previously worked at the Meatpacking District’s iconic Pastis until it closed in 2014, is happy to offer up his list of fall cocktail destinations with talented full-service mixologists. “Go to places that reinvent themselves often, and which stay really focused on putting together seasonal cocktails, like Death and Company,” he says. In fact, the innovative East Village mixology haven has served up a pumpkin puree and rum-driven Patois Punch, and changes its cocktail menu—viewable online—quarterly, according to season.

Conversely, you can’t go wrong with quintessential New York classics like Tavern On The Green, surrounded by the season’s changing colors. A quartet of cocktails named after New York’s boroughs grace the Tavern’s Fall 2018 beverage menu, including the “Queens” with Bootlegger Vodka, Velvet Falernum, hibiscus syrup, pomegranate molasses, and lemon juice.

“For a place so corny, they always do a phenomenal job,” Ruppert says. “All their bartenders are crackerjack, and there’s a guy with a top hat at the door. Everyone wants to be greeted by a guy in a top hat who calls you ‘sir’ or ‘ma’am!’”

Ruppert is personally fond of bars in Brooklyn, too. He recommends Hotel Delmano (“It’s not a hotel”), a rustic-style cocktail bar which divides its menu between classic and seasonal boozy creations, and which also boasts an equally seasonal raw oyster bar.

Ruppert also recommends Williamsburg’s Walter Foods. “I can tell you with a great deal of confidence that my hot toddy is one of the best you’re going to find in the city. However, I think the hot toddy at Walter Foods in Williamsburg is close competition. Robust and good-looking, at one of the coziest bars in Brooklyn.”

We convinced Ruppert to share his Lucien hot toddy recipe, which he scrawled by hand on a tabletop, so you can whip or, better yet, steam one yourself on lazier days.

“My recipe calls for piping hot water to be added and stirred,” he says. “So a couple minutes to simmer is fine. However, I usually steam mine with an espresso machine, so maybe an extra minute to set would do.”

Peter Ruppert’s Lucien Hot Toddy

2 oz. bourbon

1 oz. lemon juice

¾ oz. honey

fresh ginger

herbal tea

add piping hot water

decorate with cinnamon stick and star anise

Words Lawrence Ferber

You May Also Like

Chinese cuisine - soup, seasonings and calamari

The Spice is Right: Chinese Cuisine's Greatest Hits

food & drink
stories
Our list of iconic dishes and where to find them downtown. Fortune cookie, anyone?
cookies and crumbs on a baking sheet

A Fall Cookie Recipe & More from Janice Alida Joseph

food & drink
stories
The model-baker shares her delicious black pepper cookie recipe alongside some of her favorite local spots to satiate that sweet tooth. 
New York Art Gallery Guide Storm King Dia:Beacon Opus 40 Edward Hopper House

Escape the Everyday with these Fall Art Trips

art & design
stories
Whether you’re after an outdoor sculpture garden or a boutique gallery surrounded by upstate charm, there’s an art escape to suit.
New York's Best Openings

New York's Best Openings

bars & nightlife
food & drink
restaurants
stories
From an intimate French wine bar in "Dimes Square" to a 4000-square-foot brasserie, we round up the best new spots to try.
5 Compact Overnight Bags for all your Weekend Trip Essentials

5 Compact Overnight Bags for all your Weekend Trip Essentials

fashion
shopping
travel
stories
Skip baggage check and get to your destination quicker thanks to these five carry-on bags from brands rethinking how we travel. 
Natural Organic wine Guide NYC Wildair Ten Bells Frenchette Racines Hemlock

Natural High: The 5 Best Wine Bars Downtown

food & drink
stories
If you ever needed a reason to drink wine, this is sure to be it.
NYC Restaurant Week's Best Tables

NYC Restaurant Week's Best Tables

food & drink
restaurants
stories
We've sorted through the hundreds-long list to bring you the very best reservations downtown.
Weekends in Williamsburg

Weekends in Williamsburg

bars & nightlife
fashion
food & drink
restaurants
stories
From a wine bar co-owned by LCD Soundsystem's James Murphy to a veritable treasure trove of vintage finds—our guide to the eclectic Brooklyn neighborhood.
Best Rate Promise
Soho Grand Hotel

310 West Broadway
New York, NY 10013

(212) 965-3000
The Roxy Hotel New York

2 6th Avenue
New York, NY 10013

212.519.6600