Bagels with cream cheese, toppings, and a mug of coffee

Grandlife guide

THE HISTORY OF NYC BAGELS AND WHERE TO EAT THEM

back to list

Behold the New York bagel and its long, fabled history. Dating back to ancient Egypt, the glossy dense bread made its Manhattan cameo in the early 19th century after an influx of Eastern European immigrants started a union called The International Beigel Bakers Union with the sole purpose to make, yes, bagels. Once upon a time, the Lower East Side’s Orchard and Delancey Streets were once dotted with bagel shops. “New York City also had a huge Jewish community,” says Black Seed Bagel Executive Chef Dianna Daoheung. “Bagel baking used to be very sacred, and in order to even be a baker, you would have to be male, Jewish and in the union.” After a massive strike in the 1930s, bakers were replaced by folks from “other ethnic communities, which began the evolution of bagels becoming a bread for all,” says Daoheung.

Once the floodgates opened, old-school venues like the now-defunct H&H Bagels jump-started the movement in 1972 by opening their first specialty storefront dedicated to producing freshly-baked, perfectly ring-shaped bagels. And, by the ’80s, hungry New Yorkers had fallen in love with the pillowy treat. Then came the cascade of casual mainstays like Ess-A-Bagel, Murray’s Bagels, and the beloved 100-year-old Lower East Side branch of Russ and Daughters, which continues to serve the iconic breakfast-into-lunch staple, often using toppings such as chopped scallions and caviar cream cheese, and, of course, its famed silky, hand-cut lox.

There are also new variations. Montreal-born Black Seed  (pictured) came along with a hybrid mix, incorporating the texture of a New York bagel with a smaller size, boiled and baked in a wood-fired oven for the ultimate chew. “Our dough is very New York-style, made from sourdough starter and boiled in New York water,” explains Daoheung. Noting that unique Canadian spin, Black Seed tweaks the time-honored Gotham preparation by first hand-rolling, then boiling the dough in a kettle of honey water and baking in a wood-fired oven for a smoky, crisp crust.

And while the delicious taste of the bagel has long been attributed to the city’s water, many brick-and-mortars outside of NYC often skimp on ingredients like malt, quality flour, and even salt. Take Black Seed again, they mix King Arthur high-gluten flour to score the chewy texture on the outside and softness inside, while the brand’s gluten-free bagel uses Cup4Cup flour. Really, though, New Yorkers all seem to agree that like the slice of their favorite pizza, toothy bagels are the stuff of legend. From sesame to onion to everything to…really, it’s a question of whether you toast yours or not.

Words Kate Donnelly

You May Also Like

Chinese cuisine - soup, seasonings and calamari

The Spice is Right: Chinese Cuisine's Greatest Hits

food & drink
stories
Our list of iconic dishes and where to find them downtown. Fortune cookie, anyone?
cookies and crumbs on a baking sheet

A Fall Cookie Recipe & More from Janice Alida Joseph

food & drink
stories
The model-baker shares her delicious black pepper cookie recipe alongside some of her favorite local spots to satiate that sweet tooth. 
New York Art Gallery Guide Storm King Dia:Beacon Opus 40 Edward Hopper House

Escape the Everyday with these Fall Art Trips

art & design
stories
Whether you’re after an outdoor sculpture garden or a boutique gallery surrounded by upstate charm, there’s an art escape to suit.
New York's Best Openings

New York's Best Openings

bars & nightlife
food & drink
restaurants
stories
From an intimate French wine bar in "Dimes Square" to a 4000-square-foot brasserie, we round up the best new spots to try.
5 Compact Overnight Bags for all your Weekend Trip Essentials

5 Compact Overnight Bags for all your Weekend Trip Essentials

fashion
shopping
travel
stories
Skip baggage check and get to your destination quicker thanks to these five carry-on bags from brands rethinking how we travel. 
Natural Organic wine Guide NYC Wildair Ten Bells Frenchette Racines Hemlock

Natural High: The 5 Best Wine Bars Downtown

food & drink
stories
If you ever needed a reason to drink wine, this is sure to be it.
NYC Restaurant Week's Best Tables

NYC Restaurant Week's Best Tables

food & drink
restaurants
stories
We've sorted through the hundreds-long list to bring you the very best reservations downtown.
Weekends in Williamsburg

Weekends in Williamsburg

bars & nightlife
fashion
food & drink
restaurants
stories
From a wine bar co-owned by LCD Soundsystem's James Murphy to a veritable treasure trove of vintage finds—our guide to the eclectic Brooklyn neighborhood.
Best Rate Promise
Soho Grand Hotel

310 West Broadway
New York, NY 10013

(212) 965-3000
The Roxy Hotel New York

2 6th Avenue
New York, NY 10013

212.519.6600